GSO003 Problem 7
Problem Statement
Thomson Experiment with Exact Trajectory Geometry
Problem Statement
In a three-dimensional Cartesian coordinate system (x,y,z), an electron (mass m, charge −e, e>0) is accelerated from rest through a potential difference V and injected from the origin (0,0,0) in the +x direction with initial speed v0. Gravity and relativistic effects are negligible.
Step 1: Velocity Selector In the region 0≤x≤L, a uniform electric field E=(0,E0,0) and a uniform magnetic field B=(0,0,B0) are applied simultaneously. The injected electron travels straight along the x-axis without any deflection.
Step 2: Magnetic Deflection The electric field is turned off (E=0), while the magnetic field B remains. The same electron with initial speed v0 is injected again from the origin. Inside 0≤x≤L, the electron is deflected by the Lorentz force and follows a curved path in the xy-plane, exiting the magnetic field region through the plane x=L.
Step 3: Drift Space The region x>L is a field-free drift space. The electron travels in a straight line and hits a fluorescent screen (parallel to the yz-plane) placed at x=L+D. The y-coordinate of the impact point on the screen is recorded as displacement Y.
The instrument is precisely set up with drift length D=3L. The observed displacement on the screen is exactly Y=(3−3)L.
From these results, find the specific charge e/m of the electron.
Important: Do not use any small-angle approximation (such as sinθ≈θ or y≈L2/(2R)). Derive the result using exact geometric relations.
Constraints
- Uniform electric field strength: E0=1.76×104V/m
- Uniform magnetic flux density: B0=1.0×10−3T
- Length of magnetic field region: L=5.0×10−2m
Input Format
The specific charge e/m can be written as A×1011C/kg for some real number A.
Compute 100A and give the answer as a positive integer.
Solution
1. Velocity Selector (Step 1)
The electron velocity is v=(v0,0,0).
Electric force (−y direction): FE=−eE=(0,−eE0,0)
Magnetic (Lorentz) force (+y direction): FB=−e(v×B)=(0,ev0B0,0)
For straight-line motion, these must balance:
−eE0+ev0B0=0⟹v0=B0E02. Exact Circular Orbit in the Magnetic Field (Step 2)
With the electric field off, the electron undergoes uniform circular motion. The radius R satisfies:
mRv02=ev0B0⟹R=eB0mv0The electron starts at the origin moving in the +x direction and curves toward +y, so the center of curvature is at (0,R). The circular orbit equation is:
x2+(y−R)2=R2At x=L, the exit y-coordinate y1 (with y1<R) is:
y1=R−R2−L2=R(1−cosθ)where θ is the deflection angle satisfying:
sinθ=RL,cosθ=RR2−L2Using the half-angle formula (1−cosθ=2sin2(θ/2), sinθ=2sin(θ/2)cos(θ/2)):
y1=sinθL(1−cosθ)=Ltan2θ3. Drift Space and Total Displacement (Step 3)
In the field-free region, the electron travels at angle θ to the x-axis. Additional y-displacement over distance D:
y2=DtanθTotal displacement on the screen:
Y=y1+y2=Ltan2θ+Dtanθ4. Determining the Deflection Angle
Substituting D=3L and Y=(3−3)L:
tan2θ+3tanθ=3−3The left side is strictly increasing for 0<θ<π/2, so the solution is unique.
Testing θ=30∘ (using tan30∘=1/3, tan15∘=2−3):
(2−3)+3⋅31=2−3+1=3−3✓Therefore θ=30∘ is the unique solution.
5. Computing the Specific Charge
From sin30∘=1/2:
RL=21⟹R=2LUsing R=eB0mv0 and v0=B0E0:
R=eB02mE0⟹me=RB02E0=2LB02E0Substituting numerical values:
2LB02=2×(5.0×10−2)×(1.0×10−3)2=10−7 me=10−71.76×104=1.76×1011C/kgA=1.76, so 100A=176.
Answer: 176